If I ever was cool, which seems unlikely, that period in my life ended a while back. I read someone recently who was bashing Chris Tomlin for his lack of originality, claiming that Chris Tomlin just covered lots of songs from other artists. What I found interesting about the accusation was that the person implied that to be cool, to be genuine, to be interesting, you had to be unique and original.
Now I have no desire to get into a debate over Chris Tomlin, his music, or his lyrics, but the thought that “real” Christianity and “authentic” worship music was found in originality struck me. I was left with the impression that to be noteworthy, you had to be original and unique. I wonder how biblical that claim is. In our culture, we have become obsessed with “being our own person” and “doing what is true to us.” We think that to be real, we have to be different than everyone else. To copy what someone else has done is a great sin because copying demonstrates a lack of uniqueness and individuality. We seem not to have progressed past children on the playground who yell “copycat!” at those who imitate what someone else has done.
But biblically I find that we are all copycats. I used to be annoyed by Paul’s incessant claims that people should imitate him. Who is Paul to say that anyone should live like him? I am my own person, and I have to set out my own journey in life. But all Paul was saying is that he was setting the example by following Christ. We are all Christ followers, and we only follow others to the extent that they follow Christ.
Uniqueness and originality have their place I suppose. God gifts us all in unique ways, and he gives us all different ministries in the context of his body. But we are all copycats. We have been called to follow the example set forth by Christ Jesus, and we are called to imitate others who have gone before us in following Christ’s lead.